Reflecting on my experience about encyclopedia and Wikipedia, I would say both resources are great learning tools. However, there are merits and demerits to each types of resource. For example, one of the encyclopedia on my topic is "Gay History and Cultures: An Encyclopedia" written by scholars and experts in the field and edited by George E. Haggerty and co-edited by John Beyon and Douglas Eisner. The good thing about this encyclopedia is that it was compiled and supervised by group of reputed experts and Advisory Board from different reputable universities around the globe. Notable among them are Harvard University, University of Michigan, Toronto University, Yale University, New York Law School to mention a few.
Apart from this, there are numerous contributors from all works of life making the encyclopedia a good source of information serving wide audience, including students, scholars in all fields, and the public, who is interested in gay population the research. Again, the encylopedia above contain the name of the publisher, author's name and bibliography that make it more authentic.
On the other hand, some of the posting on Wikipedia lack credible source since the posting were posted by volunteers with some anonymous name, making it difficult to verify the authentication of posting. Nonetheless, my search topic on Wikipedia was very fruitful. For example, I looked at LGBT history on wiki; it gave me an insight of how my chosen population began, the perspective of people toward them, their movement and struggle and at the end a references, external links, and suggested further readings.
Overall, both sources have their ups and downs. However, the source of any information especially for academic and research purpose should be verified.
Hi Taiwo,
ReplyDeleteThank you for your post on encyclopedias and Wikipedia.
Did you locate an entry in one of the traditional encyclopedias to compare to your Wikipedia entry?
How did that entry compare with your Wikipedia entry?
I look forward to your response.
Sincerely,
Professor Wexelbaum
Yes ma'am. The encyclopedia was located in the MS Refrence section at SCSU Library.
ReplyDeleteThe Encyclopedia entry is pretty similar to Wikipedia entry in terms of style, author's credibility and currency. The Wikipedia entry is more flexible and upgraded, and easy accessible anywhere anytime once you have access to internet.
ReplyDelete